Captain Shaun O'Malley was not about to lose this opportunity to enforce the "new law". He found Molly Finn very attractive in a seductive way and he did not want the opportunity the law now afforded him to disciple and humiliate the wench for his own satisfaction. Then too, Molly Finn's public humiliation would be popular with the old biddy's of the town folk and administering discipline publicly would satisfy the urges Molly had awakened in many of the men.

The possibility that she might run away from town was not to happen. The two deputys were instructed not just to escort her home but to remain with her. One deputy was to be with her no matter what. This included even as she performed a woman's most intimate functions. The men looked forward to the prospect of seeing Molly bathe and use the toilet. Even as she slept one deputy was to remain awake with her.

Molly had protested but it had done no good. She dressed in a long gown which allowed her some discretio as she sat on the toilet. She did not bathe, but rather was able to wipe her body with a cloth under the gown. Thus she spent the miserable night in the company of the two men. Molly was terrified by her ordeal at the store and dreaded what might happen in the morning.